Dan Meyer

Total 1628 Posts
I'm Dan and this is my blog. I'm a former high school math teacher and current head of teaching at Desmos. He / him. More here.

We shook up the world!

You mean you don’t do your professional development here? Man that sucks.

Asilomar, see you next year. Readers, see you later this week. I’ve gotta recharge.

The Complete List

Asilomar #9: Asia
Asilomar #8: The Future
Asilomar #7: Excel
Asilomar #6: PowerPoint
Asilomar #5: Hooks
Asilomar #4: Friday Keynote
Asilomar #3: Green Knowledge
Asilomar #2: Proportions
Asilomar #1: Motivation
Asilomar 2007

For Your Consideration

Ross for Boss. Vote dy/dan best new edublog and best individual edublog.

Asilomar #9: Asia

Session Title

“Putting a Face on Mathematics in Asia: Reflections on My Work of 20 Years”

Presenter

Steve Rasumussen. President, Key Curriculum Press. Hawaiian shirt aficionado. Guy you want to buy a beer.

Narrative

Generally awesome. Completely evenhanded, doing justice to all sorts of tricky issues facing education (NCLB, international competition, TIMSS) without once resorting to the pandering, cheap irony which plagued Friday’s keynote.

In his duties as publisher-in-chief with Key Curriculum Press he’s spent a good portion of the last twenty years in Asia. A lot of it was just as you’d expect. “You have no idea how easy our job could be,” he said, and cited:

  • students who stand up when a teacher walks into the room.
  • nations which devote extraordinary resources to education. (eg. 60% of Thailand’s paper went to its schools a few years back; during lean times schools are the last to cut spending)
  • schools so modern with desks and floors so clean you could safely perform an appendectomy on top of them.
  • teachers who must take 32 post-graduate classes before teaching math.

He adjusted my perspective in a couple of ways:

  • He called us out for a “tremendous national chauvinism.” He said, “If you ever hear competition [with Asia] in the same breath as education, either implicitly or explicitly, be wary of the person saying it.” He cited Thomas Friedman.
  • He explained why students in Asia outpace us in basically every benchmark except “skin whiteness.” He noted that Asian countries have huge populations with comparatively few universities. The competition for university acceptance is so fierce students take no exception to longer school days, longer school years, and three hours of math homework nightly, none of which the teacher ever grades.
  • Radical pedagogy in the U.S. involves online coursework, wikis, and podcasts. Radical pedagogy there, he said, involves a student initiating a question. Charge it to respect for their teachers and fear of appearing weak alongside their classroom competitors but it’s direct instruction all day long. Go figure.

Presentation Notes

PowerPoint for the occasional quote but for the most part he just commented over an iPhoto slideshow which was a really good way to go.

Homeless

  • “I’ve basically got a secret life in Asia,” he said at the start, and then realized what that sounded like.

For Your Consideration

Reannexation of the edublogosphere. Vote dy/dan best new edublog and best individual edublog.

Asilomar #8: The Future

Session Title

“Math 20-20 Vision: What Will K-8 Math Education Look Like in 2020”

Presenter

Keith Devlin. Consulting Professor, Stanford. NPR’s “Math Guy.” Avid gamer.

Narrative

A: World of Warcraft. (No, seriously.)

Presentation Notes

Numbing. PowerPoint. Font size dipped below 7pt, at some points, I swear. From moment to moment I had no idea where we’d been or where we were going. Not unrelatedly, I dozed off for several long stretches.

Homeless

  • Dude is a big fan of World of Warcraft. Thought I’d mention that again.
  • Who collects royalties on that “20/20 vision” phrase? Karl?

For Your Consideration:

Standing against liveblogging. Vote dy/dan best new edublog and best individual edublog.

Asilomar #7: Excel

Session Title

“Algebra Techniques Using an Excel Spreadsheet”

Presenter

Chris Mackenzie. Teacher, Palomar Valley High School.

Narrative

This guy has pitched a tent in the SCUD missile-marked territory between me and Christian Long. I suspect Christian would’ve enjoyed this guy’s unabashed amateurism, how he acknowledged at the start that he was just a teacher, not an expert, that he just really liked Excel’s applications for Algebra. When anyone corrected his math or technique, he’d say “You’ve discovered one of my weaknesses” or “Wow. That is a really good question.”

I was blogging inside of fifteen minutes, as soon as it became clear he wasn’t going to teach us anything. We were just going to talk, one amateur to a bunch of others.

Maybe this is only me but I would have been entirely unoffended had he baldly asserted his expertise and taught me how to make some of his dazzling โ€“ truly dazzling โ€“ Excel spreadsheets, with sliders that controlled variables which manipulated some beautiful graphs.

But in one-and-a-half hours I learned one Excel term (“CONCATENATE”).

That’s all.

Presentation Notes

He would open up Excel file after Excel file and demonstrate their operation but not their construction. For ninety minutes. He chided those of us who had opened up unrelated browser windows but, I mean, come on: if your kids are bored in class, is that their fault? Or yours.

Homeless

Testaments to advance planning: his laptop’s hard drive failed the day before and he didn’t anticipate that every computer in the lab would be running Vista and Office 2007. Whoops.

Sufficient Megapixels

For Your Consideration

Nixon’s the one. Vote dy/dan best new edublog and best individual edublog.

Asilomar #6: PowerPoint

Session Title

“Beginning Math Lesson Delivery by PowerPoint and Tablet PCs”

Presenter

George Krukis. Teacher, Lodi High School.

Narrative

I figured I oughtta attend since I’ll be stealing this guy’s slot next year. I felt a little guilty afterward, though, ’cause Krukis and I have a lot in common.

  • We are both designers by necessity, not by training.
  • We both use PowerPoint everyday. (Keynote in my case.)
  • We both run through a thousand slides in a school year and both find our thousandth slide far superior to our first.
  • We both use PowerPoint’s animation (and Keynote’s builds) to help us recall the pacing and structure of a lesson year after year.
  • We both dig how you can strengthen a slide slightly after each delivery and how those fortifications are preserved and compounded year after year.
  • We both acknowledge that PowerPoint is a means, not an end.

There are many significant differences between us, though.

  • He wasn’t using a wireless remote. One of the best parts of projecting images onto a wall is untethering yourself from the whiteboard (this has some cool implications for classroom management, which I’ll get to eventually) but Krukis untethered himself from the whiteboard only to re-tether himself to a laptop four feet in front of it. Whoops.
  • We both recognize the power in a standardized PowerPoint template, though, for Krukis it’s a matter of time saved where for me, it’s a matter of decreasing cognitive load.
  • He uses clip-art. I use photographs. Clip-art is dead.
  • While I think he fully appreciates how helpful PowerPoint can be in small ways, day-in, day-out, I don’t think he appreciates the damage small things (like light green text on a purple background) can inflict over a year.
  • If he’s heard of (pick any three) Reynolds, Tufte, Kawasaki, McLuhan, or Abela, I’ll eat my conference badge. Fact is, a little graphic design instruction goes a long way to improve clarity in the classroom, a fact which I’ll exploit next year.

Presentation Notes

I think we can all agree you’d better have your presentation game right if you’re gonna talk about PowerPoint. In spite of his obvious, better-than-average facility with the medium, dude loaded his slides with a lot of text which he read word for word, a fact which alone is a disqualifier in my book. He’s got enthusiasm in the right places but he hasn’t reached out far enough for free and available expert advice. (cf. amateurs & experts.)

Homeless

  • He’d take screenshots from movies and insert math-related thought- or word-bubbles. That was cool, fun, worth stealing.
  • There was a guy in the second row so enthusiastic (murmuring, yeah, mm, yeah, that’s cool, hey that’s great) he could’ve been a plant. (Note to self: recruit a plant next year.)
  • Song of the session: “Girl From The North Country,” Bob Dylan, which is probably the only Dylan song I’ve played more times than never. After the session, on the way to lunch, some lady half my height and twice my age struck up a conversation and sang all three verses of a parody she wrote to satirize her remedial math kids. Weird.
  • Recovered my appetite and enjoyed chicken thai salad with the rest of the SLV math team. Good times.

Sufficient Megapixels

For Your Consideration

Prosperity for the edublogosphere’s families. Vote dy/dan best new edublog and best individual edublog.